Mommy Evolution

Mom Smarter!

50+ Candy Alternatives for Halloween Trick or Treating

by 127 Comments

Halloween means trick or treating, costumes and sugar comas for children across America. But if you’re like many parents, you’d like avoid the sugar comas for your kids.

What kind of items can you hand out during trick or treating or at school parties that kids will find exciting? Here are 50+ candy alternative ideas for you to hand out at Halloween this year!

You can find many of these items at your local party supply store or purchase through the affiliate links provided for your convenience.

50 Candy Alternatives to Handing out Candy on Halloween -- Skip the sugar, not the fun! | The Jenny Evolution

50+ Candy Alternatives for Halloween Trick or Treating

Small Plastic Novelty Toys

Kids love small toys. My son will covet the smallest items for weeks. And Halloween time is no different. There are so many items and options you can get at party supply stores, online novelty sites and super craft shops.

 Plastic “Dress-Up” Items

Don’t forget how much kids love pretending and dressing up. All these items are perfect for both boys and girls.

School Supplies

School supplies may seem boring at first glance, but buying items in Halloween or fall themes makes these items fun.

Healthy Snack Options

You can still give out food treats without giving out sugar-heavy food. For people who are giving out treats, healthy food alternatives for trick-or-treaters:

A little candy isn’t going to hurt anyone, right? But offering candy alternatives to kids teaches them Halloween can be fun without overdoing it on sugar.

Plus, let’s not forget kids who have food allergies. There’s a great program called the Teal Pumpkin Project, dedicated to raising awareness of food allergies and promoting the inclusion of all trick-or-treaters throughout the Halloween season. Please consider how you can include all kids in your Halloween celebrations this year.

Here are some affiliate links to our favorite and biggest hits over the years:

Shipping is FREE with Amazon Prime or $35+ orders. Sign up for a FREE 30-Day Amazon Prime Trial HERE. Along with FREE shipping you will get access to thousands of movies, tv shows, books and music for FREE!

Looking for more great Halloween ideas? Be sure to check out my collection of Halloween tips, ideas, activities, recipes and more for the entire family.

CandyAlternatives

Comments

    • We’re giving out glow sticks. And from responses to this post, it sounds like giving away something other than candy is a pretty popular thing to do — for parents and kids!

      Reply

  7. I LOVE OrientalTrading.com for Halloween goodies! They have tons of affordable stuff that isn’t candy. I work for a mall, and for Halloween we always give out something reflective or light-up for visibility at night and safer trick-or-treating! This year, we are giving reflective necklaces with Halloween characters.

    Reply

  8. This is fantastic. I’m broadcasting this to the world! My kids get WAY too much candy… and then I help them eat it! My kids love stickers and dress up and glow in the dark teeth… so look out Halloween… there WILL be less candy this year!

    Reply

  9. This is a fabulous post and it couldn’t have come at a better time with Halloween approaching and all :o) Great tips; I love all your ideas especially because I don’t give my toddler candy! I’m pinning this now and thanks for linking up to The PINcentive Blog Hop! Hope you’re having a great Wednesday :o)

    croppedstories@gmail.com

    Reply

    • Elena, Thanks for pinning. And you’re right, alternatives are just perfect for toddlers. My boys just loved these plastic spider rings they came home with last year. It was a much bigger hit than the candy bar they ate and then forgot.

      Reply

    • Rubber ducks rock, right? I actually think we’re handing out glow sticks this year. Although I’m sure a bag or two will end up in the house — courtesy of my husband!

      Reply

  12. I think this is a great post. I’m not a big candy at halloween fan, I think it can be kind of scary if people are putting anything into the candy. Not to mention the sugar. I think school supplies are great. Kids might have more fun with the fake teeth or fun little gadgets. Thanks for linking up with us at Wine’d Down Wednesday.

    Reply

    • Bonnie — This is the first year I’m giving up the candy. Well, the boys are going to bring home plenty anyways! And the vampire teeth we’re handing out will last much longer 🙂

      Reply

  14. These are great ideas! Thank you for sharing them on our What We Love Wednesdays link up party and for taking the time to come up with all of them for us to use this Halloween! We can’t wait to see what else you have in store!

    Reply

  16. Love this! The one thing I hate about halloween is all the candy, we end up tossing half of it. I will definitely be looking at some of these options to give out this year. I’m sure the other parents will also appreciate getting something other than more sugar! haha!

    Reply

  17. Thanks for sharing! My kiddo has some severe food allergies among other things. Halloween is our roughest time of year. Alternatives are so appreciated!

    Reply

  18. One of our neighbors gives nickels and dimes. She’s a huge hit! Another one of our son’s favorites is glow stick bracelets. Thank you for the great list!

    Reply

  19. Because of Hurricane sandy, we opted out last year… I’m totally hoping to offer to buy the good chocolate to opt out again. I find Halloween weird but then I didn’t grow up doing it.
    Thanks for hooking up to the Hump Day Hook Up

    Reply

  23. This is so great. My husband and I were just discussing when we were going to take our son trick-or-treating. He’s only eight months old now, and we were thinking “At what age will he be able to have some of that candy?” Frankly, we still haven’t decided. I wish more people gave out fun stuff like supplies and toys.

    – April

    Reply

    • April — Personally we waited until our sons turned one to have sugar and cake. I think that’s how their love of vegetables started. (Yes, the highlight of dinner is picking out which vegetable they’re having!) Let me know what you end up handing out for Halloween 🙂

      Reply

  24. Yay! Thank you so much. I hope more people see this. My kid’s favorite items every year when we go trick or treating are the non-candy items! It is often cheaper and easier to buy a bag of candy, but with so many food allergies in kids out there, these alternatives are a great idea!

    Reply

    • That’s interesting that your kids love the non-food items. One person said they were afraid to get egged if they didn’t give out candy! And you’re right about the allergies. I’m allergic to nuts, so I understand the issue with Halloween candy.

      Reply

  26. This is a great list! I have always thought if you don’t give out candy, you run the risk of getting your house egged! Haha! But there are some really great ideas here that kids will love! Plus, it will be some thing fun and different and I think you might actually get some bonus points for giving out something fun! I will be pinning!

    Reply

    • Let me know if you decide to go that route! I’m always curious what people’s experiences are. This is our first year going candy alternative. But the boys will still bring home plenty of candy home for a good sugar buzz 🙂

      Reply

  28. What great ideas! My husband and I don’t have children yet, but next month we are moving to a neighborhood where Halloween is HUGE. We’ve been told to prepare for hundreds of trick-or-treaters. I don’t like the idea of spending big bucks on huge bags of candy, but a trip to the dollar store for a few of these fun items might be a big help for us. Thanks for these ideas! I would not have thought of them otherwise 🙂

    Reply

  30. This is a great idea…I wouldn’t have thought of any of these! Candy, candy, candy…I mean, really, how much can you eat? Well, if it’s up to my kids, pounds and pounds of it! This sounds like way more fun, too!

    Reply

  31. This is great! I love the costumes & parties at Halloween but don’t always like all of the sweets. We have given other items instead of candy (or w/ candy at times). It is a great alternative. I plan to bookmark this for use next month. Thanks again for taking the time to put this all together. It looks like it took quite a bit of time.

    Reply

    • We all could use something other than candy at Halloween. I know my kids will get their sugar fix and then they’ll have something to play with from my hand-out bin.

      Reply

  33. Thank you thank you thank you! I am an avid Halloween lover and I love to let my kids go door to door for candy and other items but I loath bringing home all that candy! We never finish it all, ever. In fact sadly I think we still have leftovers from last year. Handing out other options like the fake tattoos is a great idea. My girls would go gaga over those.

    Reply

  34. These are great suggestions! My daughter doesn’t even like candy, so I’ll be keeping some of these in mind for Halloween this year!

    Reply

  35. Great list of alternatives.

    We get so few kids in our neighborhood that I’ve stopped buying anything and turn the light off. I got to the point that I was buying candy we like because we would have it left over. But we don’t need it either! lol

    Reply

  40. I’m a magazine Editor, and I’m working on a story designed to provide tips, tricks and party ideas for Halloween. Thank you SO much for this post! Lots of cool ideas to jumpstart my brain. I wanted to include a small section on alternatives for costumes – how cool to find alternatives for candy! 🙂

    Reply

  41. Love this list! I am always looking for creative little items to use instead of candy and this list has tons! Thank you, Mary

    Reply

  42. I LOVE the idea of alternatives for candy! I’ll admit, when I was a kid I enjoyed getting little treats like a toy or sticker way more than candy. I think even then I knew they’d outlast a piece of candy, so I appreciated it. I’ve passed out cute pencils and stickers to our trick or treaters in the past, I think I’ll do it again this year.
    Thanks for sharing.

    Reply

  43. You had some awesome ideas on here. I think it would be great to incorporate both candy, healthy snacks and toy novelties for your Trick or Treaters. And I try to also remember each year that it is a treat. My kids don’t gorge themselves with candy all year long…although I’m sure they’d love that LOL.

    It’s nice when my girls have a mix of toys, pencils and candy treats on Halloween. They really enjoy it. And I let them have their candy fill (4-5 pieces usually) and then call it a night. I often take a lot of the leftover candy to work for my co-workers. And I might snag a few pieces for myself as well 🙂

    Reply

    • My husband is going to adopt all of the leftover candy. I wanted to hand out something other than candy this year. I know my boys will get a blast out of the glow sticks and spider rings I’m handing out.

      Reply

  44. Great ideas! I have never gotten anything aside from candy so I think this would be great if more people implemented it. Not everyone, though. I love Free Candy Night. Lol

    Reply

    • Jean, I’m so glad you like the list and that you’ll be sharing it with your daughter. Readers who have commented on this post have said that if they handed out glow sticks last year, they were a huge hit.

      Reply

  46. Great ideas! We’ve given out glow sticks for the past 3 years instead of candy and the kids are always super-happy to get them because they’re different and fun. And I feel better b/c leftover glowsticks sure have fewer calories than leftover candy after the last trick-or-treater is gone!

    Reply

  47. Thanks for all the great ideas. :] I remember being very underwhelmed by apples as a kid, but I would have loved little toys, probably. It was almost a game with my sister and I to make our Halloween candy last until Christmas, and I have to admit, my kids still have candy in the cupboard from last year. :]

    Reply

    • Jennie, Apples were the worst, weren’t they. That and those homemade popcorn balls, which we weren’t allowed to eat anyway because they weren’t prepackaged.

      I’m impressed your kids still have candy from last year! My husband would have gladly taken care of their candy for them 😉

      Reply

    • Ha! Jenn, I would agree with you 🙂 I was ALL about the candy. But I remember my sons going gaga over the spider rings they got last year. I think I’m headed in that direction.

      Reply

  54. Each year we try to move farther and farther away from the trick or treating. This year we are doing a scarey movie night with healthly snacks at home.

    Reply

    • I think as the kids get older it will be easier to not do the trick or treating. But when they’re in elementary school it’s THE THING to do. But when my kids were younger, they were completely freaked out by trick or treating.

      Reply

  55. As a kid, I only went trick or treating twice. I had to beg to do that. We don’t give out candy either. I will def pass these ideas along to friends and neighbors because they are too cute not to share.

    Reply

    • Awww. Thanks for sharing. 🙂 We always went trick or treating as kids. But as a grown up, my kids bring home so much candy I just didn’t need extra in the house!

      Reply

  56. You do have some great ideas. When children are young, it just seems mandatory to do the trick-or-treat halloween things. I am happy to say that now I really don’t participate at all, we don’t get any trick or treaters, and the cats refuse to wear costumes. Life is good!

    Reply

  57. These are fun. I remember as a kid that I hated getting pencils and pennies 🙂 Our neighborhood is lame and we don’t get any trick-or-treaters, but when I have friends with kids over, I always have bowls of activity kits, finger puppets, stickers and crayons. It really makes it more fun than sitting around with the adults, though we all sometimes get into it to 🙂 I love the idea of bubbles, so maybe if some new people move to our neighborhood and we get any little ones coming around, that will be my new alternative!

    Reply

    • You’re right. Pencils and pennies are lame. (However, a woman down the street handed out dimes and I guess the kids went wild.) We’re handing out glow sticks, spinning tops and vampire teeth. It should be fun handing them out. This is the first year we’re going candy alternative!

      Reply

  58. Honestly, I have really not looked into Halloween stuff….I come from a country where the celebration is different…and here I have not had a reason to look into that stuff….Last year I had some candy out..but the kiddos did not show up–the neighbors had warned that kids do not show up on that street……

    Reply

  60. O joy’…this is great and a bummer all at the same time. You’re crafty and that’s awesome. I love visiting blogs that show their crafty side. I always go seeking out other help once the holidays come up. But of course that means that the holidays are rapidly approaching!! Ugghh. love them and hate them all at the same time. My favorite part of this post are the suggestions for the healthy snack.

    -FS-

    Reply

  61. Some great stuff in here – I always worry about my kids and them getting carried away with Candy at Halloween, so thx v much! Thanks so much for linking up to the Parenting Pin it Party this week as well 😀

    Reply

  63. Thank you so much for not actually listing any place these items could be found. ..made this so much more useful. *groan*

    Reply

  65. This will be the first year that I have actually been able to hand out “treats” for Halloween, thanks to my daughter joing Girl Scouts and her troop participating in a trunk or treating event. I opted for a non-candy item to give out and so far have decided on pencils. Hopefully it goes over well in our area and the kids are happy with what they get!

    Reply

    • We’re handing out glow in the dark vampire teeth (we have older boys in the neighborhood), styrofoam planes and whirley whistles. From the reaction of my own boys, I know they’ll go over well. This is the third year I’m handing out non-food items.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Categories

EVOLVE OR GO BACK TO BED!

Get My Weekly Newsletter.
CLICK HERE.